|
Journal of Substance Abuse
Treatment, Vol. 8, pp. 75-82, 1991 Printed in the USA. All rights reserved. |
|
0740-5472/91 $3.00 + .00 Copyright © 1991 Pergamon Press
plc |
|
PERSONAL
PERSPECTIVE |
|
Altered States
of Consciousness Therapy |
|
A Missing Component in Alcohol and Drug
Rehabilitation Treatment |
|
JOHN D. McPeake PhD, BRUCE P. KENNEDY,
MEd, AND SHARON M. GORDON, MA |
|
Beech Hill Hospital, Dublin, New Hampshire |
|
Abstract-Attaining
altered states of consciousness is described as a
basic human motive. The substance dependent population is distinguished from
other populations because they pursue these states destructively by
inappropriate use of alcohol and drugs. Despite a body
of literature supporting the benefits of altered states of consciousness, alcohol and drug
rehabilitation treatment programs fail to address this motive because of social disapproval, means-end
confusion, and inadequate staff training. The authors maintain that
Alcoholics Anonymous directs its members toward an altered state of consciousness called a spiritual
awakening, which replaces the self-destructive pursuit of substance induced
"highs. "Failure to address patients' need for alternative methods of achieving altered states of consciousness is presented as
part of the reason for relapse. An Altered States of Consciousness Therapy (ASCT)
program is described that can be used to teach patients to consciously
manipulate affect and cognition to achieve a new consciousness. |
|
Keywords-altered states of consciousness; Alcoholics
Anonymous; therapy; relapse; 12 steps; alcohol and drug rehabilitation
treatment. |
|
ALCOHOL,
NICOTINE, CAFFEINE, prescribed tranquilliz |
|
ers, and illicit
substances, for example, marijuana, cocaine, and opiates, are widely
employed in the United States for the purpose of altering mood, mental state,
and consequently behavior. Alcoholics and other drug-dependent patients, as
well as other substancedependent people, for example, bulimics and anorexics,
self-destructively pursue alterations in feelings, thoughts, and behaviors
through substance use. Part
of the pathology of addiction lies in the unbridled pursuit of the altered
states of consciousness (ASC) associated with the substances used. Even experienced
clinicians and researchers are frequently amazed at the sacrifices that
addicted individuals are willing to make to continue to use substances and to |
|
Requests for
reprints should be addressed to John D. McPeake, Vice-President for
Therapeutic Services, Beech Hill Hospital, Dublin, NH 03444. |
|
experience the states of consciousness induced by them. A
voluminous literature emerged in the 1960s and
1970s exploring the
antecedents of altered states of consciousness, the characteristics of the
states themselves, as well as the behavioral consequences of such
experiences (Tart, 1969; Weil, 1972).
While some of this literature was devoted to the
production of altered states through substance use, most of the literature
was devoted to alterations in consciousness produced by other means, for
example, meditation, physical exercise, massage, biofeedback, hypnosis, etc. In
the literature referred to earlier as well as in the present article, ASCs
refer to states of consciousness that are qualitatively different from
ordinary waking consciousness. They appear to be distributed on a continuum
based on how different they are from normal waking consciousness and from
each other. As employed here, it is suggested that a normal untrained human
observer can distinguish, for example, normal |
|
75 |
|
76 |
|
J.D.
McPeake et al. |
|
waking consciousness from dreaming, normal
waking consciousness from sleeping or unconsciousness, normal waking
consciousness from alcohol- or drug-induced intoxication, normal waking
consciousness from states of sexual or religious ecstasy, normal waking
consciousness from consciousness during peak experiences, or normal waking
consciousness from trance. This usage is similar to that employed by Tart
(1969), Weil (1972), and Harre and Lamb (1983). Weil (1972) noted the apparently ubiquitous nature of
techniques used to experience nonordinary or altered states of consciousness.
He noted that the experience of nonordinary consciousness seemed so compelling
and universal as to represent a common human motive. He also noted that
without an opportunity to experience altered states of consciousness in
constructive, ritualized, socially approved ways, individuals would seek
other, less desirable ways of achieving this end. He argued that despite the
significance of this need, our culture makes little provision for such
experiences other than through the use of alcohol. In the face of the facts that substance-dependent
people seek self-destructively to alter their consciousness as part of their
illness and that people in general are motivated toward such alterations in
consciousness, it is surprising that alcohol and drug rehabilitation
treatment programs spend so little time addressing these issues. Most such
programs make little or no effort to systematically expose patients to
constructive alternative methods for experiencing nonordinary consciousness.
Even where minimal efforts such as stress management or meditation are
present as part of a treatment program, they are rarely integrated in a
manner that addresses the relationship between recovery and altered state
issues. What makes this even more surprising is that Alcoholics
Anonymous (AA), which serves as the bedrock of much alcohol and drug
rehabilitation, clearly directs its members toward an altered state of
consciousness. The 12th step of AA directs the member actively involved in
the steps toward a change in "consciousness and being" called a
"spiritual awakening." This state of consciousness and its
maintenance is the goal of all the steps and replaces the negative,
self-destructive pursuit of substance-induced "highs" with what AA
regards as the true, positive, life-enhancing "high," the spiritual
awakening. The failure to understand the need for such ASCs
and the failure to see that AA directs individuals toward such experiences
by a different method represents a curious lacuna in therapy for addiction.
Some portion of the outcome variance associated with relapse may be
explained as a failure to address the issues considered here. The purpose of
this article is to explore why treatment has ignored the pursuit of ASCs and
to further delineate AA's pursuit of such states. The nature of ASCs in
general will be explored as well |
|
as suggestions
for a new type of therapy offered as an integrated component of alcohol and
drug rehabilitation: Altered States of Consciousness Therapy (ASCT), which
will be outlined. |
|
THE ETIOLOGY
OF SUBSTANCE DEPENDENCE |
|
Attempts to explain substance dependence have
become increasingly sophisticated, particularly since the identification of
the genetic basis of alcoholism (National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and
Alcoholism, 1985). There is widespread agreement that substance dependence
is determined by many variables: drug availability, drug choice,
environmental stressors, genetic predisposition, peer, family, and broader
sociocultural attitudes and practices, etc. Usually in discussions of the
etiology of substance dependence, the use of alcohol and other drugs to
manage dysphoric thoughts, feelings, and emotions is also emphasized. Thus,
while it is common to use negative internal states as one of many variables
explaining dependence, it is rare to find substance dependence explained by
the desire to experience more sought-after states. These otherwise
sophisticated explanations leave out the "joy," "ecstasy,"
"bliss," "buzz," and "high" so often described
by the drug-dependent person as the state being sought. Some researchers have, however,
pointed in the direction of the pursuit of new experiences and altered
consciousness as a central element of drug use, abuse, and dependence.
Naditch (1975) identified experience and/or pleasure seeking as one of the
three primary dimensions of motivation for using drugs in a college
population. Segal, Cromer, Hobfoll, and Wasserman (1982) identified an
expanded awareness-insight motive as one of three reasons for drug use among
adjudicated juveniles. Zuckerman (1970, 1979) has demonstrated that
sensation seeking, the individual's tendency to seek out varied, novel, and
complex experiences, is closely associated with substance abuse and dependence.
Jaffe and Archer (1987) compared several objective inventories, using normal
subjects, including the MMPI Pd scale, the MacAndrew Alcoholism Scale (MAC),
the Millon Alcohol Abuse Scale, the Millon Drug Abuse Scale, and the
Sensation Seeking Scale (SSS). They concluded that the SSS score was most
closely associated with the primary reason given by their subjects for using
substances. Weil (1972), from a more clinical perspective,
argued that the need to alter one's state of consciousness emerges
developmentally in children and that some of their play, such as spinning to
dizziness or holding their breath, is specifically designed to produce
nonordinary consciousness. As children develop, the adult world discourages
such practices, and consequently such activities disappear or go
underground. One promise society holds out is that later, alcohol may be
enjoyed to |
|
Altered States of Consciousness Therapy |
|
77 |
|
accomplish the same result.
Meanwhile, children and adolescents continue approved and disapproved practices
to experience ASCs such as listening to music or using drugs other than
alcohol. Weil (1972) argued that attempts to suppress such practices are doomed
to failure because these practices represent a primary motive. Strivings to
experience ASCs are consistent with some of the highest and most noble
spiritual and religious goals of humanity. While individuals may use alcohol
and drugs to attain states similar to those attained by meditation, prayer,
fasting, etc., such states are transitory and illusory. Individuals need to
learn that permanent and beneficial altered states of consciousness may be
attained without drugs and, further, that drug use impedes such attainment. There is good reason to believe that clinical research
and clinical opinion confirm that an important motive for all individuals who
use substances, whether they become dependent or not, is to experience new,
nonordinary states of consciousness. AA clearly suggests that the pursuit of
such states is also the aim of recovery. |
|
ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS AND THE SPIRITUAL AWAKENING OF STEP 12:
AN ALTERED STATE OF CONSCIOUSNESS |
|
AA, as well as other 12-step
programs, do not have as their goal the simple cessation of the behaviors on
which they focus. AA and Narcotics Anonymous (NA) only see not drinking and
not drugging, that is, abstinence, as a preliminary method. Abstinence alone,
that is, "being dry," is, in fact, viewed as an unhappy,
pathological state that could only be maintained with considerable pain. From
a more psychological point of view, if alcohol and/or other drugs have been
integrated into a person's life, removing them also removes important
adaptive behaviors without which the individual cannot function. The 12-step programs' methods are much more complicated than mere
abstinence. Recovering persons are expected to admit and accept utter and
complete humiliation and defeat at the hands of their addiction. They are
also expected to acknowledge the total unmanageability of their lives, the
need for total, unconditional surrender, and the fact that they cannot
recover by relying only on their own resources. It is assumed that for people
to admit these things, they must have experienced a sufficient amount of pain
and suffering (i.e., hit bottom). Next, recovering persons are expected to come to believe that only a
power greater than themselves, God, can restore them to a sound mind. Having
accepted this, they must then turn over control of their lives to God,
according to their own definition of God. This calls for the cultivation of
willingness and |
|
a new understanding of independence
and dependence, where the proper use of the will is conformance with God's
will. This turning over of control is epitomized by the Serenity Prayer,
which is offered as a cognitive strategy, particularly with its final,
frequently omitted phrase, "Thy will, not mine, be done"
(Alcoholics Anonymous, 1987, p. 41). In rapid succession, individuals are expected to assess their
liabilities in an inventory which they share with another and with God and
then become ready to have these "character defects" removed by
asking God to remove them. In these endeavors, the recovering person comes to
grips with the self as it is, becomes less isolated, experiences forgiveness,
and learns humility and honesty. Subsequently, they seek to identify and
make amends to people they have harmed and through the amendatory process to
become more insightful about the self and less isolated from others. On a daily basis, the recovering person is
expected to continue the self-examination and to admit promptly and to
correct defects of character and instances of unethical behavior continually.
Prayer and meditation are to be cultivated to improve "conscious
contact" with God and conformity to the will of God. This routine is
regarded as a method of living and a way of life to be practiced in all the
person's affairs. The result of these practices is an alteration of
consciousness and being called a spiritual awakening (step 12), which leads
to enhanced competence and behavior as described in the Promises: |
|
We are going to know a new freedom and a new happiness. We will not
regret the past nor wish to shut the door on it. We will comprehend the word
serenity and we will know peace. No matter how far down the scale we have
gone, we will see how our experience can benefit others. That feeling of
uselessness and self pity will disappear. We will lose interest in selfish
things and gain interest in our fellows. Self seeking will slip away. Our
whole attitude and outlook on life will change. Fear of people and of
economic insecurity will leave us. We will intuitively know how to handle
situations which used to baffle us. We will suddenly realize that God is
doing for us what we could not do for ourselves. (Alcoholics Anonymous,
1976, pp. 83-84) |
|
This spiritual awakening is a central issue in
recovery. Although there are differences among the spiritual awakenings of
different recovering people, AA (1987) describes the commonalties of such
experiences: |
|
The most important meaning of it
is that he has now become able to do, feel, and believe that which he could
not do before on his unaided strength and resources alone. He has been
granted a gift which amounts to a new
state of consciousness and being [italics added]. He has been set on a path that tells him he is really
going somewhere, that life is not a dead end, not something to be endured or
mastered. In a very real sense he has been transformed, because he has |
|
78 |
|
J.D.
McPeake et al. |
|
laid hold of a source of strength which, in one way or another, he had
hitherto denied himself. He finds himself in possession of a degree of honesty,
tolerance, unselfishness, peace of mind, and love of which he had thought
himself quite incapable. What he has received is a free gift, and yet
usually, at least in some small part, he has made himself ready to receive
it. (pp. 106-107) |
|
It is interesting to note that some spiritual
awakenings are dramatic and unusual, whereas most are slow, gradual, and
ordinary. Further, people who have had such experiences, while powers of
example within the AA fellowship, are seen as relatively ordinary, nonmystical,
individuals. |
|
WHY ARE ASCs EITHER IGNORED OR NOT
INTEGRATED INTO ALCOHOL AND DRUG REHABILITATION TREATMENT? |
|
commonly offered or understood by
treatment professionals as an important goal of treatment. This may in part
be simply an extension of the social repression described above, or it may
suggest a lack of training among professionals about recovery from substance
dependence. It may also stem from a failure to see that the 12 steps are part
of a long historical tradition of altering consciousness through spiritual
discipline. Spiritual discipline, of course, is at variance with the
materialism that dominates the culture presently and accommodates
therapeutic, psychological, psychiatric, and medical interventions as real
while perceiving spiritual interventions as somehow "not
professional" or "unrealistic." While some parts of medicine,
notably cancer treatment, are moving to integrate spiritual variables into
recovery, the very field that points in that direction, addiction treatment,
seems to be rejecting its roots. |
|
Despite the rich literature on
ASCs in psychology and spiritual writings, and despite the fact that AA
clearly points its members toward an ASC, reviewing the published literature
on rehabilitation treatment or surveying current rehabilitation treatment
programming reveals a paucity of writing or treatment programming that
clearly integrates ASCs with recovery. Despite this, some methods that have
historically been used to achieve ASCs are included in treatment and recommended
by some writers as responses to selected treatment problems, for example,
relaxation, meditation, art, physical activities, cognitive therapy, video
and audio experiences, hypnosis, and biofeedback: Such techniques are rarely
consciously employed as illustrations of producing ASCs or as illustrations
of the potential benefits of such altered states of consciousness. It would seem that there are several reasons why ASCs are not specific
goals of nor integrated into alcohol and drug rehabilitation treatment.
First attempts to achieve ASCs are generally socially disapproved. This may
stem from the social perception that such alterations in consciousness have
an inherently revolutionary and socially subversive quality (Tart, 1969;
Weil, 1972). Others argue that such experiences are potentially personally
dangerous, linked to depression, psychosis, or self-destruction, and
therefore need to be carefully prescribed and controlled. Second, ASCs have become so intertwined with one method of achieving
such alterations, namely, taking substances, that people reject the method
and the goal simultaneously without giving this confusion much thought. The
tremendous harm with which the use of licit and illicit substances has been
associated during the past few decades often has prevented calm discussion
of the underlying needs for consciousness alteration that are implicit in
substance use. Further interpreting the steps as
a route to a permanent alteration in consciousness and being is not |
|
ALTERED STATES OF CONSCIOUSNESS THERAPY:
UNDERLYING ASSUMPTIONS |
|
It is necessary to help substance
dependent patients understand and accept their need to experience altered
states of consciousness. They need to be exposed to substance-free methods
that can be utilized to achieve ASCs. These attempts are called Altered
States of Consciousness Therapy (ASCT), which are a natural compliment to and
lead in the direction of the 12-step recovery programs discussed earlier.
This program is predicated on the following set of assumptions: 1. ASCs are defined as alterations in
consciousness awareness, predominantly subjective experience, which may be
produced by a variety of methods, that is, prayer, meditation, relaxation,
hypnosis, biofeedback, exercise, fasting, etc. 2. ASCs may have some unique behavioral or physiological
characteristics, but are primarily defined by the subjective report of
individuals that their consciousness is different from normal in some marked
or qualitative way. The correlates of these differences may be defined by
such characteristics as positive mental attitude, goal directedness, certain
types of cognitions or self talk, certain types of imagery, as well as
consciousness of a power greater than self. 3. Every person has a desire to alter his or her
state of consciousness from time to time. As in other motives, this may vary
in individuals from a more intense to a less intense need. 4. Experiencing ASCs leads ultimately to personal
growth and development and may be associated with what appears to be
"super normal" behaviors. These behaviors are not super normal but
are within the behavioral range of any normal person who wishes to invest
time and effort in personal development. |
|
Altered States of Consciousness Therapy |
|
79 |
|
5. The potential to have ASC experiences is an innate
characteristic of the nervous system. 6. The underlying neurochemical substrates of
ASCs will be found in the rapidly expanding field of endorphin/enkephalin
neurotransmitter research as well as related research evidence for endogenous
neurochemicals that are analogues/agnonists to other exogenous substances of
abuse (Goldberg, 1988; Pert 1986; Pert, Ruff, Weber, & Herkenham, 1985;
Snyder, 1986). 7. ASCs can be arranged hierarchically from transient,
impermanent states produced by exogenous methods with modest potential for
personal growth and development, to more permanent states that are
endogenous, within the individual's control, and that lead to potentially
dramatic and positive changes in functioning. 8. Drug-dependent individuals have become stuck,
as a result of genetic predisposition, using alcohol and other drugs to
produce ASCs and, therefore, are stuck in a life-threatening situation. 9. The treatment of choice for many such
addicted individuals is abstinence from alcohol and other drugs combined with
treatment based on AA or other 12-step programs that emphasize a spiritual
methodology to attain a particularly sophisticated and desirable ASC called a
spiritual awakening. 10. Recovering individuals will be aided in their recovery
by being taught to experience many different ASCs. This allows them to enjoy
and benefit from nonsubstance-induced ASCs as well as to learn the
general characteristics of ASCs. 11. The goal of this process is to enhance
the individual's ability to attain the spiritual awakening described in step
12 of AA. |
|
AN ASCT PROGRAM
IN PRACTICE: PROGRAM COMPONENTS AND THERAPEUTIC PROCESS |
|
Using ASCs in practice means first educating
patients and staff to the fact that the steps point the way toward
alterations in consciousness and that nondrug-induced alterations in
consciousness are desirable. Preceding portions of this article, as well as
the assumptions listed earlier, present the key ideas and topics that need to
be discussed with both groups. Inservice training of staff and patient
education seminars addressing these issues provide the framework within which
ongoing therapeutic activity is interpreted. |
|
ation, offer
mechanisms for appropriate ventilation of emotion, and provide behaviors for
more effective use of leisure time. Although exercise has been frequently
cited as a source of an ASC, for example, "runner's high,"
opportunities for patients to utilize exercise for this purpose do not seem
common. In an ASCT program, the feelings engendered during exercise are explicitly
connected to ASCs. Patients are taught that physical activities access some
of the same neurochemical subsystems of emotion and feeling that are activated
by alcohol and drug use. Physical activities staff focus patients'
attention on the positive feelings they experience during physical exercise
and its relationship to a spiritual awakening. Patients are shown, and
experience, the benefits of the physical activity both mentally and
physically. Furthermore, it is suggested that this is similar to, although
not as powerful or as intense as, the spiritual awakening that can emerge
through practicing the steps. Adventure-based activities are also included
among the physical activities offered to some of the patients. Rock climbing
is used for the opportunities it presents to enhance communication among
patients, engender trust, enhance self-esteem through overcoming an apparently
difficult task, and as a metaphor for the recovery process. When such
exciting and strenuous activities are utilized, the altered state components
are identified and processed by the treatment team. For example, during rock
climbing, there are almost always some frightening and anxiety-provoking moments.
During such moments, or shortly afterwards, participants often experience
"natural highs" that are combinations of sympathetic nervous system
arousal, and satisfaction and relief at accomplishment of the climb. Focusing
attention on such alterations in consciousness contributes to patients'
understanding that alternative highs are available and again suggests the
similarities to AA's spiritual awakening. These activities are offered as
beginning methods for achieving an ASC without alcohol or other drugs. It is
explained to patients that physical activities are preferable to substances
as methods of achieving ASCs and serve as a metaphor for the process of
attaining nondrug-induced ASCs. These are not the primary treatments for the
patients' illnesses, but are activities that will assist them while they move
toward a more complete recovery. |
|
Relaxation Training |
|
Physical
Activities |
|
Physical
activities such as running, aerobics, weight training, and swimming are
included in the treatment program as methods to encourage physical wellness,
serve as examples of healthy competition and cooper |
|
Relaxation
training is one of the most common and obvious methods that we employ.
Originally suggested by Jacobsen (1938) and popularized in the work of Wolpe
(1958), progressive relaxation has been modified and influenced by many
schools of thought. It has become a technique that is ubiquitous in alcohol
and |
|
80 |
|
J. D. McPeake et al. |
|
drug rehabilitation and psychological and psychiatric treatment
for many disorders, and is a cornerstone of behavioral medicine. In relaxation training,
patients learn physical exercises that contrast the subjective feelings when
muscles are tensed followed by attention to the feelings in the same muscle
groups when they are relaxed. Patients learn to be attentive to increases in
muscle tension in target situations and with practice gain some control over
the onset of anxiety. Often, breathing control techniques borrowed from yogic
disciplines are paired with muscle relaxation techniques. Frequently, this
relaxation training is coupled with an exploration of cognition's or
"self-talk," which are sometimes seen as the "worry"
component of anxiety and which are translated into physical tension, for example,
"This is a terrible situation. I'm not going to survive this. I can't do
this." Through a variety of cognitive-behavioral techniques, patients
learn to still such cognitions and substitute for them more constructive
reality-based cognitions, for example, "This is a difficult situation
but I can survive it comfortably if I reach out for help from my therapist
and fellow patients. Other people have survived such events and so will I.
Now calm down and practice your relaxation exercises." In addition, patients
are often taught the use of vivid imagery that supports efforts at relaxation
and calmness, for example, imagining themselves functioning in a specific
and effective manner, experiencing enhanced self-esteem, etc. While undergoing such
training, patients often report spontaneous alterations in consciousness. Patients
say they "feel better" or "feel different," and such
changes in consciousness are linked by treatment staff to the specific
activities in which they have been involved: relaxation training, self-talk,
and imagery. The essential message
for the patient is that through specific behaviors and mental activities,
they can alter consciousness as they did taking alcohol or other drugs. It is
suggested that the patients are accessing the same neurohormonal and brain
pleasure-pain centers that they did when actively drinking or drugging, only
now they are doing so without substances. Patients seem excited by the
concept that they can bring these very same neural systems under some type of
voluntary control in a healthy manner. Patients are taught that to gain
mastery with this technique, they need to practice daily. |
|
prime example of this is the use of the Serenity Prayer, which is
employed regularly with patients to help them sort out cognitions and
behavioral strategies into those that need to be acted upon and those that
need to be "turned over." Once patients learn to use this type of
cognitive strategy, they often are much better prepared for dealing with the
recovery process with its many unsettling events. Patients learn that when
they successfully employ a cognitive strategy, they alter their feelings and
mood states, that is, they alter their state of consciousness. Thus, a patient who learns
that his wife has decided to separate from him can be coached to assess what
he can constructively do to make a difference in the situation. He can
grieve and discuss with others his loss, fear, anger, and anxiety. He can
express his concern to his wife with honesty and vigor while recognizing that
he cannot control the behavior of another person. He can try to recognize and
empathize with his wife's pain and suffering while he was actively using substances,
and he can hope for reconciliation based on his demonstrated willingness and
ability to refrain from alcohol and drugs and change his life. Moreover, he
can concentrate on his own recovery because substance use will only worsen
an already difficult situation. Since ventilation and cognitive restructuring
of this sort is often new to patients, it can be a model for a whole array of
techniques that are, in the long run, better than drugs for creating positive
feelings. The whole "slogan
and saying" aspect of the recovery movement is full of similar opportunities
for cognitive reformulation and cognitive strategies, all captured in pithy
aphorisms. "Live and let live" helps sort out interpersonal
interaction. "All you have to do is not drink or drug"
constructively uses denial in early recovery. "Bring the body the mind
will follow" seeks to overcome the early confusion and resistance of the
newly recovering person overwhelmed by the multiple tasks of recovery. The Tip of the Iceberg (1983) summarizes
the use of such tools in recovery. When patients develop the
ability to use the
Serenity Prayer, the slogans and sayings, or other cognitive techniques,
they often report a sense of calmness, a sense of being in control, a
freedom from worry that is new to them. This subjective experience represents
an important aspect of an ASC, a new consciousness that can be used again to
illustrate the direction in which recovery should be moving. |
|
Cognitive Therapy |
|
Most alcohol and drug rehabilitation programs utilize overtly or
covertly some form of cognitive therapy in their treatment armamentarium
(Beck, Rush, Shaw, & Emery, 1979; Ellis, 1962; Meichenbaum, 1977). The |
|
Art/Aesthetic Experience |
|
One common outcome of artistic activities is the turning of
patients' attention away from obsessional concern with self, other, and the
world and a focus on manual activities, sensory input, perceptual, and aesthetic
processes. Sometimes this results in periods of |
|
Altered States of Consciousness
Therapy |
|
81 |
|
non-awareness,
somewhat similar to meditation, culminating in the "high" of
creating a very personal and unique piece of art work. Similarly, such an
experience can be obtained from contemplation of a work of art. Such
activities are often utilized in treatment for their enhancement of
self-esteem, the opportunity they present to teach improved leisure time
skills, and their possible value in reducing isolation and fostering
communication. These activities are used
to emphasize their connection to altered states of consciousness. Patients
are encouraged to understand that their creative or aesthetic experience is
similar to the consciousness obtained from using alcohol and drugs. They are
asked to consider the artists who have lost their creative and inspirational
genius through the use of alcohol and drugs. |
|
Meditation and Prayer |
|
Meditation and prayer, which are specifically
recommended to the recovering person in step 11, are also employed in the
treatment program. Meditation is framed within the context of chapter 11 of Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions (Alcoholics Anonymous,
1987). The patients are encouraged to read the chapter and follow the simple
instructions outlined in the step in conjunction with the Prayer of St. Francis. The
instructions are: |
|
. . .
reread this prayer several times very slowly, savour every word and try to
take in the deep meaning of each phrase and idea . . . drop all resistance .
. . rest quietly with the thoughts . . . so that (you) may experience and
learn . . . as though lying upon a sunlit beach . . . relax and breathe
deeply of the spiritual atmosphere with which the grace of this prayer
surrounds (you) ... become willing to partake and be strengthened and lifted up by the sheer spiritual
power, beauty, and love of which these magnificent words are the carriers.
(When distracting thoughts occur about the process think of how much time was
wasted fantasizing with alcohol and drugs.) Perhaps the real trouble was our
almost total inability to point imagination toward the right objectives ...
read the prayer again try to see what its inner essence is ... think now
about the man who first uttered the prayer ... he asked for the grace to
bring love, forgiveness, harmony, truth, faith, hope, light, and joy to every
human being he could ... this much could be a fragment of meditation. (pp.
99-101) |
|
Patients are asked either to use the pray of
St. Francis or to choose some other such work that provides them with
inspiration, and meditate on aspects of this that they find meaningful. This
is often a difficult task for patients, and readings more consistent with
their belief systems and values are adapted to their needs. Sometimes it is
useful to encourage patients to use Eastern techniques, that is,
transcendental meditation or Zen-like meditation that involve focus |
|
on
mantras or problems (koans). The therapy staff may modify these techniques
and employ AA slogans and sayings as the point of concentration. This type of meditative practice builds on concepts and techniques the patient has already learned at an earlier point in treatment. Patients are initially introduced to these concepts in educational seminars. The concepts are elaborated by the patient's clinician who provides specific instruction and guidance to help develop the |